Thursday, 13 November 2014

Do you see your body as your biggest indicator of success (or failure)

So - here's a blog / ramble I've been thinking about but been too scared to write for a while now - scared because it's possibly a bit controversial and I'm not into conflict!!

It's also a bit of an insight into how my mind works and how much of a mind boggle this whole self acceptance journey can be - I still alternate pretty regularly between thinking I should lose weight and thinking I should focus my time and energy on other things.

What I have been pondering is this - why do so many of us see our bodies as our biggest (and sometimes only) indicator of success or failure?

Why do we spend so much time, energy and money trying to achieve the "perfect body"? Or worrying that we never will?

Isn't this just the ultimate display of vanity and self-absorption? Not to mention a mechanism for torturing ourselves and always feeling like we aren't good enough.

But then again you could argue that starting a blog is pretty vain and self-absorbed too - why do I think people care what I have to say?

Still, wouldn't this time, energy and money be better spent on other pursuits? When did we stop working towards ending hunger in Africa and start working on looking good in a bikini?

I also love dressing up, curling my hair and wearing make-up - does that make me a hypocrite?

Am I just feeding into making people feel guilty now? That is not my intention - it certainly does seem like there is always a reason to feel bad these days. I spend plenty of money on things I don't need and time playing mindless iPhone games - so who am I to judge anyone else for what they spend their time and money on?

All of the "fitpso" images say "strong is the new skinny". Why is this seen as being "inspirational"? I'm more inspired by the women who are actually out there making a difference in the world. I'm inspired by people who overcome adversity to achieve great things, and I'm inspired by people who have the dedication and commitment to do things like run marathons, but I don't think visible abs are particularly inspiring.

Why do we congratulate people who have lost weight and tell them we are proud of them? Sure, it takes a lot of hard work - but so do lots of other things. Why do other successes seem to pale in comparison? Why is the internet filled with before and after weight loss photos and not of people getting degrees? When was the last time you complemented someone on their empathy, joyfulness or for being a good friend?

I've started this post by saying some pretty inflammatory things - there's probably people reading this thinking that I'm just jealous that I'm not skinny. Well yeah, I still have pretty regular thoughts about being "too big". I tried on some new clothes the other day and I looked in the mirror and I thought "Geez, I am huge!" My point is - so fucking what if I'm huge?!

Yes, we should look after ourselves - we need to sleep, play, eat a balanced diet and get some exercise.

But this body obsession - I just don't think it's good for us as individuals or for the world. Think about what else you could be achieving - you are so much more than your body. What about the things you are putting off until you lose weight? Why can't you do them now?

I'm confused about how I feel about this myself because I'm all about "my body, my business". If you want to focus on becoming faster, stronger, leaner, and that makes you happy then more power too you, but I guess I am wondering if maybe obsession with our bodies is the modern day opiate of the masses?

I'm not saying that people shouldn't have goals relating to fitness or anything else that relates primarily to the self. It's good to challenge yourself - it's what makes life interesting! I think what I'm really ranting against is when this focus on the body becomes all consuming and something that robs us of our self-esteem and happiness. It's the lack of balance in the messages we receive - which all seem to say we are only good enough if we have a "bikini body" - nothing else seems to matter. Maybe you will never have a six pack or run a marathon and that's ok!! Maybe you can discover the cure for cancer instead! Maybe you are good at making people laugh, maybe you give awesome hugs! Maybe you donate to charity. All of these are things you can be proud of. There are a million ways to be an awesome person that have nothing to do with your body fat percentage.

Why don't we celebrate our bodies as a vehicle for all that awesomeness instead of trying to change them all the time?

As I said - I've been ruminating on this for a while now and still feeling pretty torn about my position. Please know that I am not trying to attack, judge or shame anyone. I'm far from perfect, I still obsess about my body, I have fitness goals and I am definitely not over in Africa making a difference. Maybe I am just overthinking the whole thing? 

Does it all just boil down to the fact that we all have different goals, lifestyles, ideals, aspirations and dreams, and that that is ok?

When does it stop being about individual goals and start becoming about being sucked in by the multi-billion dollar diet and beauty industries?
 
Where is the line between health and obsession? And is obsession always a bad thing?

I thought I'd put this all out here and see what you all think - I'd love to hear your thoughts.

2 comments:

  1. Wow Lauren, I resonate so strongly with this post. Personally, this point is the number one thing I work on in therapy and in the projects I do these days. Whether or not, I personally wish my body to be at a different size, strength or endurance capability, or anything else physically related, I am not my body. My heart, character, ability to love, risk, be kind, be hateful, be proactive, rumminating , obsessed, lazy, hardworking, focused -- all of the wonderful soaring things and typical stumbles that make us human come from places outside of the scale and calorie book. It is difficult in our society to feel comfortable in our own skin. We are bombarded by images of what "we should aspire to physically". Much harder to find the same for what to aspire to as a human being living our best life. And the interesting thing is, that I believe posting true thoughts, as you have done here, IS a heroic step to making that happen.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a great point: as I work hard at getting and being healthy, is the size and shape of my body the proof or lack of it? NO. I don't always believe it, but no, it isn't. My resting heart rate, cholesterol, fasting glucose--those all attest to my good health.

    ReplyDelete